GNSO Whois Task Force Chair: "...when making a post to a blog (which may get republished elsewhere),
can you please make sure that people know it is your opinion..."
I wonder if this is Jeff's personal opinion or the official position of the Task Force. Maybe Neustar's policy position.
Policy nonsense nothwithstanding, there are some interesting syndication related issues here. Although I've never publicly stated this, I wouldn't be too impressed if someone started editing my content post-syndication for re-publication elsewhere. I don't mind the republication, but modifying my words to state something else (even if it is consistent with my position) is just uncool. Just because what I post is easily accessible doesn't mean that what I post is in the public domain.
1BTW - the headline is a wisecrack...don't take it seriously. ICANN has no position on RSS.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
ICANN on RSS and Syndication<sup>1</sup>
by
Ross
at 01:47PM (EST) on December 27, 2003 | Permanent Link
Posted to: Random Bytes/Code
Comments
Re: ICANN on RSS and Syndication<sup>1</sup>
by a reader (name not saved) on Sat 27 Dec 2003 02:05 PM EST | Permanent Link
Wouldn't a Creative Commons license clarify this? For example, you can set your use to allow no modifications. Re: ICANN on RSS and Syndication<sup>1</sup>
by a reader (name not saved) on Sun 28 Dec 2003 12:26 AM EST | Permanent Link
Off topic Re: ICANN on RSS and Syndication<sup>1</sup>
by a reader (name not saved) on Mon 29 Dec 2003 10:17 AM EST | Permanent Link
FYI. That was my own personal opinion. After that article was posted, I got a couple of e-mails as the Chair of Task Force, both from members of the Task Force and Non-members asking how it was that we came to a conclusion so fast and that we were not doing our job (which is to collect information). The Task Force was accused of having an agenda and that there was no way the work could be done in an objective manner. Re: ICANN on RSS and Syndication<sup>1</sup>
by a reader (name not saved) on Tue 30 Dec 2003 05:32 PM EST | Permanent Link
As an occasional author and publisher, I'd have to say, I agree with Ross here:
"I wouldn't be too impressed if someone started editing my content post-syndication for re-publication elsewhere. I don't mind the republication, but modifying my words to state something else (even if it is consistent with my position) is just uncool. Just because what I post is easily accessible doesn't mean that what I post is in the public domain."Weblogs and Collaborative Open Publications (COPubs -> think weblogs plugged into amplifiers) are quietly shaking the traditional news-publishing world -- partly because they are delivering first-hand non-manufactured news/opinions/information directly from source to readers and vice versa. Modifying the words of the author in this process would be like serving diet pop with sugar. Since discussions on the issue of modifying content appear to have been initiated from Wendy's post, I should also point out that CircleID firmly holds this standard regarding modifying content (even grammatical corrections) as I have clarified here and here. The issue expressed by Jeff is not (the way I'm reading it) about CircleID modifying what the author had intended to say but an overall suggestion to authors telling readers that words are their own opinion and not the opinion of the organization they belong to. And of course authors can freely choose to add this byline, be it on their own Weblog or CircleID. Trackbacks
TrackBack URL: Weblogs that reference this article:
|
Blogroll 2.0
Make a Donation to the Tour For Kids!
Search
![]() "Random Bytes" is a produced for and by Ross Rader. Everything else is just a happy byproduct. The views expressed here belong to me and not my employer.. Contact Me
Feel free to use my contact information to get in touch for work related items. email: ross@tucows.com tel. +1.4165385492 cel. +1.4168288783 MSN. ross@tucows.com Local Topics
Recent Articles
Recent Comments
Recent Visitors
jamessmithforum - Tue 15 Dec 2009 03:21 AM EST
ahmed100 - Tue 08 Dec 2009 06:49 AM EST
Andrew C - Fri 04 Dec 2009 09:57 PM EST
maxvoice - Mon 30 Nov 2009 06:33 AM EST
ahmed1212 - Thu 19 Nov 2009 09:20 PM EST
Login
|
||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||


